Troubleshooting of Inserted Screw: Loose Inserted Tube and Blocked Circulation
Release time:
2026-11-09
An external tube-type ball screw shares the lubrication and wear problems of an internal-return design, but it adds two failure modes the internal type does not have. Both are more dangerous than ordinary wear, and either one can stop the whole machine.
Two Failure Modes Unique to the Tube Type
Loosened return tube, and blockage of the recirculation channel. Wear develops slowly and gives warning; these two usually do not. A tube that comes away from the nut releases the balls from the circuit, and the nut can seize within seconds.
This is why routine inspection of a tube-type screw has to include items an internal-return screw simply does not need: tube fixation, joint sealing, and signs of grease weeping at the nut.
Spotting and Handling a Loosening Return Tube
Warning signs
- A regular, repetitive knocking noise that appears once per revolution and is localised near the tube.
- Grease seep marks along the tube or at either end of it.
- The tube can be felt to move, or a gap is visible between tube and nut body.
- Axial play that increases suddenly rather than gradually.
Emergency response
Stop the machine immediately. A loose tube can detach; the balls then leave the circuit, the raceway is destroyed, and parts can be thrown. Never continue running in this condition, not even to finish a cycle.
Corrective action
- Slight looseness: remove the nut, clean the groove and re-fix the tube — re-bond, or re-weld where the design calls for welding.
- Deformed tube, or a damaged groove in the nut: send the assembly back; the tube set has to be replaced as a matched group.
- After any repair, run a full-stroke circulation test under rated load and confirm there is no knocking, hesitation or grease loss at the joints.
Spotting and Clearing a Blocked Recirculation Channel
Where blockage comes from
- Foreign matter — swarf, grit — entering through the ball ports or past a failed tube joint seal.
- Grease that has dried and caked into sludge inside the tube.
- Debris from a ball that has already spalled, accumulating at the tube mouth.
- Burrs raised by a scratched tube bore, catching the balls.
Warning signs
A sudden rise in driving resistance, hesitation at one point in the stroke, a metal scraping sound, and starting torque clearly above its normal value. The keyword is sudden: gradual loss of smoothness points to wear, a step change points to blockage.
Corrective action
- Remove the nut; flush the tube and both ball ports thoroughly.
- Inspect every ball. Any damaged ball means the whole set is replaced — never mix old and new balls in one circuit.
- Re-lubricate with a grease that flows readily at the operating temperature; a grease that is too stiff will simply re-block the channel.
- Confirm the tube bore is smooth and free of burrs before reassembly.
How Tube-Type Servicing Differs from Internal-Return Servicing
The same screw in the same application needs a different maintenance plan depending on which circulation type it uses. The differences are concentrated in four places:
Lubrication focus | Lubricate the nut body as a whole | Ball ports need targeted greasing — they are the dead spots |
Extra inspection | None beyond standard items | Tube fixation, joint sealing, weeping at the nut |
Protection | Protective bellows | Bellows plus scheduled inspection of the tube area |
Repairability | Often repairable on site | Tube problems usually mean a factory return |
Preventive Maintenance Recommendations
- Inspect the tube area every three months: look for any sign of loosening and for oil seepage at the joints.
- Lubricate more actively than you would on an internal-return nut. The ball ports are the dead spots of the circuit, so inject fresh grease through the fitting regularly to flush the channel rather than just topping up.
- Keep the sealing intact: both nut-end wipers, and the sealant at the tube joints with no cracks in it.
- Control temperature rise. The tube area dissipates heat poorly, and sustained high temperature ages the bond line and degrades the grease faster than the rest of the nut.
Safety Warning
Tube detachment is the most severe failure an external tube-type screw can suffer. At the first sign of a loosening tube, stop and report it — there is no middle ground, and running on in the hope of reaching the end of the shift is how people get hurt.
The same rule applies to a metallic knocking sound coming from the nut while the machine runs: stop first, diagnose second. A few minutes of lost production is the whole cost; the alternative is a destroyed nut and an unsafe one.
Putting a Structured Maintenance Regime in Place
- Written procedure: fixed intervals, scope, method and a named owner for every item.
- Maintenance log: date, work done, findings, action taken — this becomes the asset health record.
- Spares policy: hold balls, seals, grease and preload shims; for critical plant, hold a complete screw assembly.
- Training: maintainers must understand the circulation principle, the strip-and-rebuild sequence and the fault signatures above.
- Manufacturer support: periodic technical visits and a deep health assessment using the maker's own test equipment.
Early Warning Signs of Impending Failure
- Sound — rising noise, a new rattle or a once-per-revolution knock: ball wear, raceway damage or foreign matter.
- Temperature — a rise beyond the normal 20 to 30 C above ambient: lubrication shortage, excess preload or misalignment.
- Vibration — a steady upward trend: ball damage, raceway spalling or a bearing fault.
- Accuracy — growing positioning error or lost motion on reversal: preload decay or raceway wear.
- Resistance — starting or running torque climbing: dried grease, a rusted raceway or a restricted circulation path.
- Appearance — grease leakage, a torn bellows, swarf around the nut: all of these need attention the same day.
General Principles for Handling a Fault
- Stop first, inspect second. Never keep a machine running in a known abnormal state.
- Work simple to complex: lubrication, sealing and appearance first; preload and accuracy next; internal strip-down last.
- Record everything — temperature, vibration, torque, accuracy — so the trend is visible rather than the single reading.
- Leave internal work to the maker or a qualified specialist. Do not lap or regrind a raceway on site.
Key Measures for Extending Service Life
- Use within the rated load, speed and travel; avoid overload, overspeed and overtravel.
- Lubricate on schedule with the right grease and keep the feed path open — this single habit does more for life than anything else.
- Protect: intact bellows and wipers keep particles out of the circulation path.
- Check: preload, accuracy, temperature and vibration on a fixed cycle.
- Control the environment, or specify a dedicated version in the first place — salt-spray-resistant screws, for example, where corrosion is the real enemy.
Working with the Manufacturer
- Invite the maker for periodic technical inspection rather than calling only when something breaks.
- Use the maker's test equipment for a deep condition assessment that no on-site toolkit can match.
- Agree a response commitment in advance, so a failure does not turn into a negotiation.
- Track the maker's product and process upgrades, and retrofit where the gain justifies it.
FAQ
How can I tell a loose return tube from a worn ball set?
By the pattern. Wear builds gradually and shows up as rising noise and lost accuracy over weeks. A loose tube announces itself suddenly: a knock once per revolution, grease seeping at one end of the tube, and axial play that jumps rather than creeps. If in doubt, stop and inspect — the cost of being wrong is a destroyed nut.
Can a blocked tube be cleared on site, or does the nut have to go back?
A blockage caused by sludge or swarf can usually be cleared on site: remove the nut, flush the tube and ball ports, replace any damaged balls, re-lubricate with a free-flowing grease. A tube that is burred, deformed or cracked inside cannot be repaired in the field and needs a factory replacement.
How often should a tube-type screw be inspected compared with an internal-return one?
At least quarterly for the tube itself — fixation, joint sealing, seepage — on top of the standard monthly lubrication and protection checks. Internal-return nuts have no tube to loosen, so this particular inspection burden is specific to the tube type.