Selection of Embedded Screw for External Circulation Intubation: Choice with Internal Circulation Screw
Release time:
2026-11-05
1. Understanding the External Tube-Type Design
The external tube-type ball screw is simply the other way of routing the balls back through the nut. The tube is the external return pipe that carries the balls from one end of the nut to the other, and the insert or recessed design means that this pipe sits in a groove machined into the outside diameter of the nut rather than protruding from it. That last point is what separates it from the CT and CDT protruding types covered later in the range: with CM and CDM the nut keeps a clean cylindrical envelope, which makes it far easier to fit inside a housing or a telescopic guard.
The practical consequence of recirculating the balls outside the nut body is that the design is not constrained by a deflector sitting inside the nut wall. That single fact explains most of the differences that follow: the tube type accepts larger leads, more loaded turns and longer travels than an internal-return screw of the same diameter.
2. Single Nut or Double Nut: CM versus CDM
The difference between CM and CDM is the nut arrangement. CM is a single-nut configuration that works either with a small amount of built-in clearance or with clearance taken up by the fit, so the structure is simple and compact and suits general duty transmission where reversal accuracy is not critical.
CDM uses two nuts separated by a spacer. Grinding the spacer to size preloads the pair, which removes axial play entirely and raises axial stiffness, so there is no lost motion when the direction reverses. Choose CDM for precision positioning, for machine tool axes, and for heavy-load drives where backlash cannot be tolerated. If the application only ever pushes in one direction, CM is usually the more economical answer.
3. Choosing the Tube-Type Design over an Internal-Return Screw
Compare the two families on the criteria that actually decide a design: how the balls recirculate, how much room the nut takes up, which leads and travels are realistic, how much load the nut carries, how noisy it runs, and what it costs to make. Internal-return G and GD types turn the balls back with a fixed deflector inside the nut. Tube-type CM and CDM return them through an external pipe. In exchange for a slightly larger nut envelope, the tube type takes larger leads and longer travels, can be arranged with more loaded turns, and carries higher loads, at somewhat lower manufacturing cost. The trade-off is noise: the balls change direction at the tube entry and exit, which makes the tube type run a little louder than an internal-return screw.
The rule of thumb is straightforward. Short travels, small leads, tight radial space and a requirement for low noise point to internal-return G or GD. Long travels, large leads and high load capacity point to external tube-type CM or CDM. If both sets of conditions apply, decide on the basis of which requirement the machine cannot live without.
Selection criteria: internal-return versus external tube-type
Criterion | Internal return (G / GD) | External tube-type (CM / CDM) |
Recirculation | Balls turned back by a fixed deflector | Balls returned through an external tube |
Compactness | Small outside diameter, very compact | Tube recessed; nut diameter slightly larger |
Lead capability | Limited by the deflector geometry | Suited to large leads and long travels |
Number of turns | Limited | More loaded turns can be arranged |
Load capacity | Medium | High, thanks to the extra turns |
Noise | Low | Slightly higher at the tube entry and exit |
Manufacturing cost | Relatively high | Relatively low |
4. Determining the Key Parameters
Nominal diameter and lead: start from the standard diameter and lead combinations given in the product table CM, CDM series cover nominal diameters from 16 to 100 mm and leads from 4 to 32 mm. The ratio of lead Ph to diameter d0 governs both transmission efficiency and critical speed; keeping Ph/d0 between roughly 0.1 and 0.4 is a sound starting point for most designs. A lead at the upper end of that range gives high linear speed per revolution but raises the drive torque needed and lowers the achievable resolution.
Number of loaded turns: the tube layout makes it easy to accommodate more turns, typically three to five. Adding turns raises the basic dynamic load rating Ca, but it also adds friction torque and heat, so the figure is a balance rather than a maximum to be chased. For high-duty-cycle axes, favour fewer turns and better lubrication over simply adding more balls.
Accuracy grade: choose between the positioning class P and the transmission class T, then pick a grade from 1 to 10. The tube design holds accuracy more easily on long, large-diameter screws; in this range, diameters above 50 mm can reach grade 3 or better at lengths up to 2 500 mm. Bear in mind that grade applies to the screw alone the achievable accuracy of the assembled axis also depends on the bearings, the support arrangement and the feedback resolution.
5. Tube-Specific Factors to Assess During Selection
Return tube strength: the tube takes repeated high-speed impacts from the balls. Material and wall thickness must be adequate, because a tube that deforms in service will begin to trap balls and the nut will fail progressively rather than suddenly. Ask the manufacturer what tube specification is used on high-lead versions.
Tube orientation: the position of the tubes must clear any mounting faces, keyways or housing walls. State the required tube orientation on the order drawing, otherwise the nut may arrive with the tubes facing a surface you need for fixing.
Recirculation smoothness: on high-lead, high-speed applications, check the centrifugal force and impact load the balls impose as they enter the tube. If the figures are unfavourable, reduce the speed or ask for a larger tube bend radius rather than accepting the standard layout.
6. Recommended Applications
CM and CDM tube-type screws suit injection moulding machines, die casting machines, large gantry machine tools, heavy lifting equipment and long-distance handling equipment in short, any application that needs high thrust over a long travel with a heavy load. They are the usual choice where a hydraulic cylinder is being replaced by an electric axis and the thrust requirement is high.
If noise or extreme compactness is the dominant requirement, go back to an internal-return design instead. The same applies to small, high-cycle axes in clean environments, where the lower noise and smaller nut diameter of the G and GD types are worth more than the extra load capacity.
7. Preparation Work Before Selection
Step one, define the application. Map out how the screw will actually be used: mounting orientation, whether motion is horizontal or vertical, the environment (temperature, humidity, dust, corrosion), duty cycle (continuous or intermittent), and the accuracy the machine must hold. Without this the rest of the selection is guesswork.
Step two, define the loads. Establish the maximum axial load Fmax, the normal working load, and the nature of the load smooth, shocking or vibrating. Load is the primary basis for choosing both diameter and accuracy grade.
Step three, define the motion parameters: travel length, speed, speed range, acceleration and positioning requirement. These decide the lead and the grade.
Step four, define the mounting conditions available space, support arrangement, bearing type and how the nut is fixed. Mounting conditions frequently narrow the choice of model more than the load calculation does, so settle them early.
8. The Selection Calculation Sequence
A complete selection calculation normally runs through the following sequence. Establish the nominal diameter initially, using the load and stiffness requirement against the rated load table. Fix the lead from the speed and resolution requirement. Choose the accuracy grade positioning or transmission class, plus the grade number, from the required positioning accuracy. Check life: calculate the required basic dynamic load rating Cam and confirm that the selected unit has Ca equal to or greater than Cam. Check static load: confirm that Coa is at least the safety factor fs multiplied by Fmax. Check critical speed by calculating the D·n value and confirming it is inside the permitted range. Check buckling for screws loaded in compression, by verifying the slenderness ratio. Finally match the drive: verify motor torque, power and acceleration capability against the screw inertia and the lead.
Ask the manufacturer for this calculation as a written selection report rather than accepting a part number. A report lets you see which constraint was binding and gives you something to re-check if the duty changes later.
9. Working Effectively with the Manufacturer
Technical communication with the manufacturer matters more in ball screw selection than in most component purchases. Send a complete duty parameter sheet rather than a single part number. Flag special requirements non-standard dimensions, high temperature, corrosion resistance at the outset, not after quotation. Ask for the selection calculation and the inspection report. Confirm lead time and minimum order quantity. And agree the quality standard and the acceptance method in writing before the order is placed, so that there is no argument about what constitutes a passed part at goods-in.
One further point: ask which inspection records are kept for the batch. A manufacturer who can produce the thread grinding parameters, the heat treatment curve and the finished test report for your specific units is offering something a price comparison cannot capture.
10. Common Selection Mistakes to Avoid
Mistake one: assuming a larger diameter is always better. Oversizing raises cost, inertia and space consumption; size on actual load instead.
Mistake two: assuming a higher accuracy grade is always better. Higher grade means higher cost specify the grade the process needs and no more.
Mistake three: comparing price alone. A ball screw is a precision component; the supplier's technical support, inspection capability and after-sales service are worth as much as the unit price.
Mistake four: ignoring the mounting conditions. Even the best screw cannot perform if it is mounted badly, so installation must be part of the selection discussion rather than an afterthought.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose between a CM single nut and a CDM double nut?
Use CM where the load acts mostly in one direction and a small amount of backlash is acceptable. Choose CDM where the axis reverses frequently under load or must hold position without lost motion the spacer-preloaded pair delivers the axial stiffness and zero-play reversal that precision axes need.
Why would I pick a tube-type screw instead of an internal-return type?
Because the job needs a large lead, a long travel or more load capacity than an internal-return nut of the same diameter can offer. The tube type carries more loaded turns and therefore a higher rated load, at lower manufacturing cost, in exchange for a slightly larger nut and a little more noise.
What accuracy can a tube-type screw realistically hold over a long travel?
On diameters above 50 mm, grade 3 or better is achievable at lengths up to about 2 500 mm. Beyond that, ask for the actual travel variation figures for the proposed length rather than relying on the grade alone, and remember the finished axis accuracy also depends on bearing arrangement and feedback resolution.